news invitation

In the case of Thapa v Minister for Immigration [2021] FCCA 686, the Federal Circuit Court preferred the interpretation of ‘at the time of invitation’ to include the entire invitation period which is the 60 day period from the date of invitation. 


On 11 December 2018, the applicant was invited to apply for the 189 visa in the occupation of Accountant (General). His application was later refused by Department and affirmed by AAT that his skills assessment issued by Chartered Accountants ANZ was not sufficient. 

That skills assessment was dated 21 September 2015. He then completed another one on 10 January 2019. 

This was appealed to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia in its interpretation of “at the time of invitation”. 


It was not in dispute that the applicant did not hold a current skills assessment ‘at the time of invitation’. 

The Applicant had applied and obtained the second skills assessment during the ‘invitation period’. That is, within the 60 days after the notification of invitation to apply for the visa. On the basis of Berenguel, the Court adopted the interpretation that the wording “time of invitation” was used rather than “date of invitation”, therefore the skills assessment obtained during the invitation period should be accepted. 

At paragraph 30, the Court specifically commented that clear words would need to be used should the legal regulation be intended to mean the specific date of invitation. 


This court case changes the foundational understanding of most lawyers and agents. It would be interesting to see whether this would be overturned. In the meantime, this case means that you could still apply for the General Skilled Migration visa if your skills assessment has unknowingly expired. 

Contact us to find out more.

    Tell us about your issue, we are here to help you

    Our expert lawyers who will help you

    ivy luo

    Ivy Luo

    Graduate Solicitor
    adelewan solicitor

    Adele Wan

    Head of Immigration | Solicitor (Partner)

    Need to consult with us? Book an appointment today.

    Our team will give you expert advice that has been specifically tailored to your case.

    Successful Cases

    Related news

    482 and 186 Visa Changes
    186 Visa 482 Visa Work Visa

    IMPORTANT: 482 and 186 Visa Changes

    2023/11/30 | Adele Wan
    On November 25, 2023, significant changes were implemented in the Employer Sponsored migration pathways – subclass 482 visa and subclass...
    visa cancelled
    Character Requirement Criminal Record

    Visa cancelled due to sexual crime

    2023/10/25 | Adele Wan
    In the case of Smith and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2023] AATA 3063, the...
    citizenship cancellation
    Character Requirement Criminal Record

    Victory Over Citizenship Cancellation: good character

    2023/10/25 | Adele Wan
    In the case of Jamishi and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Citizenship) [2023] AATA 3094, the Department decided...

    How we will help

    Free Assessment

    Fill in the questionnaire here and we will call you for an obligation-free assessment. During this phone call we will run through your initial concerns and needs and book in a time for a more detailed consultation.


    Our consultation session runs for 30 minutes which will allow us to present to you a detailed strategy to meet the concerns and needs you presented to us in our initial phone call.

    Our fee is $150 + GST for a 30 minute session. You can book in a consultation by calling us, emailing us or filling in the Contact Us form.

    Settling the strategy and getting started

    At the consultation, we will generally present to you a few selections of the best strategies.

    We will also balance the time required, costs and difficulty so that you can choose the strategy you are most comfortable with.

    Then we will handle everything on your behalf.

      Tell us about your issue, we are here to help you

        Subscribe to our Newsletter

        You will receive the latest immigration news and policy updates. You will also get the notification of
        our upcoming webinars & events