The former migration agent of the applicant failed to disclose his family members in the primary application. This caused the subsequent entrant application to be refused.

The case of Menina (Migration) [2002] AATA 1031 (30 March 2022) demonstrates the importance of disclosing the details of your family members in your student (subclass 500) visa application.



In November 2019, the Applicant applied for a student visa and that visa was subsequently granted to her. In February 2020, her partner sought to apply for a subsequent visa as a dependant to join her in Australia. This dependent application failed because he was not declared as the Applicant’s partner in her original application.

Although the Applicant had informed the migration agent of her partner’s details, the migration agent failed to do so due to an oversight.

The Tribunal affirmed the Department’s decision as details of an existing family member must be disclosed on the initial student visa application; otherwise, they are not eligible to be granted a subsequent visa.


What if the migration agent was negligent?

Applying the common law principles of agency, where an agent is acting on behalf of an applicant, the actions of the agent, such as the lodgement of the application form, may be taken to be the actions of the applicant.

So, no, you cannot put the blame on the migration agent. Even though the migration agent was negligent, the Applicant is bound by their actions as their omission is taken to be their omission too.



Hence, it is extremely important that you choose a professional migration agent or immigration lawyer. Do not rely solely on them. You must check the application form and lodgement details before your representative lodges any application.

At Brightstone Migration, we take all applications seriously. All our clients must check and review all letters, application forms and submissions before we submit this to the Department.

Book in a consultation with one of our lawyers today to find out more. BOOK A CONSULTATION

    Tell us about your issue, we are here to help you

    Our expert lawyers who will help you


    Rochelle Zhu

    Graduate Solicitor

    Adele Wan

    Head of Immigration | Solicitor (Partner)

    Need to consult with us? Book an appointment today.

    Our team will give you expert advice that has been specifically tailored to your case.

    Successful Cases

    Related news

    Work Visa

    485 visa opens up to more graduates

    2022/06/28 | Adele Wan
    The Subclass 485 visa (Graduate Work stream) will remove requirements to nominate a skilled occupation and to have positive skills...
    Work Visa

    Sponsorship visa for restaurant staff

    2022/04/12 | Adele Wan
    Are you thinking about how to attract foreign workers at your restaurant? Since COVID-19 pandemic, border closures and flight disruptions...
    2023 federal budget
    Family Visa Work Visa

    What does the 2023 federal budget mean for migration?

    2022/04/01 | Adele Wan
    The 2022 – 2023 Federal Budget was recently announced on 29 March 2022. Read on to find out what this...

    How we will help

    Free Assessment

    Fill in the questionnaire here and we will call you for an obligation-free assessment. During this phone call we will run through your initial concerns and needs and book in a time for a more detailed consultation.


    Our consultation session runs for 30 minutes which will allow us to present to you a detailed strategy to meet the concerns and needs you presented to us in our initial phone call.

    Our fee is $150 + GST for a 30 minute session. You can book in a consultation by calling us, emailing us or filling in the Contact Us form.

    Settling the strategy and getting started

    At the consultation, we will generally present to you a few selections of the best strategies.

    We will also balance the time required, costs and difficulty so that you can choose the strategy you are most comfortable with.

    Then we will handle everything on your behalf.

      Tell us about your issue, we are here to help you

        Subscribe to our Newsletter

        You will receive the latest immigration news and policy updates. You will also get the notification of
        our upcoming webinars & events